Engagement Rings, Diamond Jewelry, Gemstone Jewelry, Jewelry repairs

Shop Gifts for Dad & Graduation

Celebrate Father's Day and graduation season with meaningful gifts they'll never forget. From timeless pieces for Dad to standout styles for grads, find the perfect way to say "you deserve this."

Enjoy a Free Shinola Wallet With Your Watch Purchase

For a limited time, receive a free Shinola wallet with your Shinola watch purchase. Crafted with the same attention to detail and premium materials, it's the perfect companion to your new timepiece.

Shop Now

Shop all Bridal

Engagement Rings

Discover engagement rings designed to tell your love story. From timeless solitaires to custom designs, each piece is crafted to celebrate your forever.

Explore

Wedding Bands

Celebrate your commitment with wedding bands that last a lifetime. From classic gold to modern styles, each band is crafted with care and meaning.

Explore

Shy Creation

Explore

Gabriel & Co.

Explore

Judith Ripka

Explore

ArtCarved

Explore

Shy Creation

Explore

Gabriel & Co.

Explore

Judith Ripka

Explore

ArtCarved

Explore

Shop Earrings

Explore

Shop Rings

Explore

Shop Bracelets

Explore

Shop Necklaces

Explore

Take a Look Inside Our Store

Testimonials

I have been purchasing and servicing jewelry at Michael Anthony's for over 20 years. The team is professional, creative, informative and consistently provides first class service. They have a wonderful selection and have been able to source or create pieces that they may not have in stock. I would highly recommend a visit.
Eric F.

Michael Anthony in West Caldwell is the best. They are knowledgeable, honest, fair and nice. I’ve bought jewelry there and have had jewelry repaired there as well. I’ve only had positive experiences.
John G.

These people at this jewelry store are the best ever. Very welcoming and warm. Make u feel like family. Can’t do enough for you. !! Best jewelry store around !! Wouldn’t go anywhere else !!!
Carol C.

Amazing place! Got my engagement ring here and they were so helpful and not pushy at all like other places I went to. Highly recommend!
Michael S.