Engagement Rings, Diamond Jewelry, Gemstone Jewelry, Jewelry repairs

Shop Bridal

A curated selection of timeless designs crafted to honor every chapter of your love story.

Discover our collection of beautifully crafted bracelets, designed to add a touch of elegance and style to every wrist.

Explore our stunning necklace collection, featuring timeless designs and modern accents to elevate any look.

From classic studs to statement drops, our earring collection offers the perfect sparkle for every style and occasion.

Make a statement with our fashion rings, where bold designs and fine craftsmanship come together to express your unique style.

"I have been purchasing and servicing jewelry at Michael Anthony's for over 20 years. The team is professional, creative, informative and consistently provides first class service. They have a wonderful selection and have been able to source or create pieces that they may not have in stock. I would highly recommend a visit."
- Eric F.
"This my favorite Jewelry store because they always have many quality things to chose from. And I can always find just the item I want and if I can't they will either make it for me or find it for me.The staff is always very pleasant and helpful.You don't have to go to New York to Tiffany's when you have the same or better quality and choices here in West Caldwell!"
- Kathleen O.
"These people at this jewelry store are the best ever. Very welcoming and warm. Make u feel like family. Can’t do enough for you. !! Best jewelry store around !! Wouldn’t go anywhere else !!!"
- Carol C.