Join Our Email List for Special Events and Giveaways!
Testimonials
I have been purchasing and servicing jewelry at Michael Anthony's for over 20 years. The team is professional, creative, informative and consistently provides first class service. They have a wonderful selection and have been able to source or create pieces that they may not have in stock. I would highly recommend a visit.
Eric F.
Customer service is an A+++, I went to have a charm put on my bracelet and they put it on while I was waiting and showed me tons of jewelry. The diamonds are GORGEOUS, it was impossible to look away! The diamonds were some of the best I’ve ever seen and I am a big diamond shopper. Many friends told me they had amazing experiences and all was true!! Lisa is absolutely amazing at her job and showed me the layout of the entire store and what was in each case. We pulled out many items and I left with three beautiful pieces. I also started a “Wish List” where you save items you like and friends, family or yourself can go and buy them! Such a great way to save all your favorites in one place, and the staff was impeccable and patient. As mentioned prior, Lisa was amazing, and I can’t wait to go back and buy more off my wish list!
Rachel
This my favorite Jewelry store because they always have many quality things to choose from. And I can always find just the item I want and if I can't they will either make it for me or find it for me. The staff is always very pleasant and helpful. You don't have to go to New York to Tiffany's when you have the same or better quality and choices here in West Caldwell!
Kathleen O.
Michael Anthony in West Caldwell is the best. They are knowledgeable, honest, fair and nice. I’ve bought jewelry there and have had jewelry repaired there as well. I’ve only had positive experiences.
John G.
These people at this jewelry store are the best ever. Very welcoming and warm. Make u feel like family. Can’t do enough for you. !! Best jewelry store around !! Wouldn’t go anywhere else !!!
Carol C.
We've been coming here for years, and they really do such lovely work! Nice to support a local business that has great quality and service. The staff are so friendly and personable too. Highly recommend!
John & Julia M.
I have been a customer for over 50 years, I have purchased many exquisite pieces from them.. They have a great selection of items and give outstanding service. I recommend them highly.
Nancy B.
The top jeweler in our area! They couldn’t be nicer. I’ve recently had the occasion to get two watch bracelets adjusted there. The watches were not purchased from them, but they were so gracious and accommodating. They gladly adjusted the watch bracelets for a minimal charge. While I was waiting, I had pleasant conversation with many of the staff as well as the owner. There was no pressure to purchase anything. I’ve been coming to Michael Anthony Jewelers for years - whether I lived locally or not. They have beautiful jewelry and always treat their customers cordially. Highly recommend!
Michael K.
I have been going to Michael Anthony Jewelers for many many years. I won't go anywhere else. Michael is the best! Everyone there is very helpful, caring and knowledgeable!
Andrea D.
Use left/right arrows to navigate the slideshow or swipe left/right if using a mobile device
Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Press the space key then arrow keys to make a selection.
